Toilet Seat Replacements

Michael Brock
10 min readJun 20, 2024

--

Say goodbye to uncomfortable toilet seats and hello to ultimate comfort with our Toilet Seat Replacement article. We have curated a selection of top-notch toilet seats that offer the perfect balance of style, comfort, and durability. Get ready to transform your bathroom experience in just a few clicks!

The Top 6 Best Toilet Seat Replacements

  1. Clorox Antimicrobial Round Toilet Seat — Easy-off Hinges — Inhibit stains and odor-causing bacteria with Clorox Antimicrobial Round Plastic Toilet Seat, featuring durable plastic construction and Easy-Off hinges for effortless cleaning and installation.
  2. Round White Wood Chromed Metal Toilet Seat Replacement — Experience unmatched comfort and durability with the Topseat Round Toilet Seat’s hand-sand finish, stylish chrome hinges, and classic wood composition for a seamless replacement.
  3. Bone Round Soft Close Toilet Seat with Whisper Closing Hinge — Experience a quiet and secure toilet experience with the Affinity Round Plastic Toilet Seat, which stays firmly in place and eliminates slamming with its whisper-close hinge and STA-TITE fastening system.
  4. Mainstays White Elongated Wood Toilet Seat — Sturdy, Easy Clean — Upgrade your bathroom with the Mainstays Easy Clean White Wood Toilet Seat, featuring sturdy craftsmanship, easy installation, and a comfortable seat, but beware of possible lack of durability and instruction quality.
  5. Upgrade Your Commode: Mayfair 1815CP 000 Soft Toilet Seat with Premium Chrome Hinges — Transform your bathroom sanctuary with the Mayfair 1815CP 000 Soft Toilet Seat. This innovative toilet seat boasts unparalleled comfort, hassle-free installation, and exquisite chrome hinges that exude an air of sophistication.
  6. Project Source Wood White Round Replacement Toilet Seat — The Project Source Wood White Round Toilet Seat offers durability, a uniform white finish, and simple installation, making it a reliable and attractive choice for toilet seat replacement.

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

Clorox Antimicrobial Round Toilet Seat — Easy-off Hinges

clorox-antimicrobial-round-plastic-toilet-seat-with-easy-off-hinges-1

This Clorox Antimicrobial Round Plastic Toilet Seat offers more than just a functional upgrade; it boasts antimicrobial properties that inhibit the growth of stain and odor causing bacteria, keeping your toilet seat cleaner for a longer period of time. Constructed from durable plastic, this seat is designed to withstand everyday wear and tear.

With easy-off hinges, the seat is effortless to remove and reinstall for thorough cleaning, while the four underside bumpers protect your toilet bowl from scratches. The installation process is simple, with all necessary hardware included, and the seat’s sturdy design ensures a secure fit on your toilet. Though it doesn’t provide protection against bacteria, viruses, or other disease organisms, the Clorox Antimicrobial Round Plastic Toilet Seat is a reliable and attractive choice for your bathroom.

Round White Wood Chromed Metal Toilet Seat Replacement

topseat-round-toilet-seat-w-chromed-metal-hinges-wood-white-1

This round toilet seat boasts an elegant design, featuring a polished white wood finish that imparts a smooth and luxurious feel. The seat is designed for toilets with a 16.5-inch measurement from the front to the center of the mounting holes at the back.

It’s accompanied by sturdy chromed metal hinges that not only add a touch of style but also ensure durability. The installation hardware and three-year warranty provide added convenience for customers.

However, there have been reports of the screw holding the seat stripping rather quickly leading to movement of the seat. Despite this minor issue, the product continues to receive positive reviews for its sturdiness and visual appeal.

Bone Round Soft Close Toilet Seat with Whisper Closing Hinge

affinity-round-plastic-toilet-seat-soft-close-never-loosens-bone-1

Introducing the Affinity Round Plastic Toilet Seat, a soft-close marvel designed to eliminate slamming and pinched fingers. This seat features the STA-TITE Fastening System, ensuring it never comes loose and provides a secure fit. Installing the seat is a breeze, requiring only a wrench, and it can be removed quickly for easy cleaning or replacement.

The resilient plastic construction with molded-in color resists wear, making it a durable choice for any bathroom. With its whisper-close hinge and color-matched bumpers, this seat seamlessly matches any round bowl, making it an excellent replacement option.

Mainstays White Elongated Wood Toilet Seat — Sturdy, Easy Clean

The Mainstays Easy Clean White Elongated Wood Toilet Seat offers a sturdy and classy alternative to your old, worn-out seat. The easy-off hinges make cleaning a breeze, while the comfortable seat provides a pleasant experience.

Despite its decent craftsmanship, the seat lacks durability, and some customers had issues with the safety and installation process. However, overall, it’s a good value for the price and a significant improvement in visual appeal compared to its cheaper counterparts.

Upgrade Your Commode: Mayfair 1815CP 000 Soft Toilet Seat with Premium Chrome Hinges

mayfair-1815cp-000-soft-toilet-seat-with-premium-chrome-hinges-that-will-never-loosen-elongated-whit-1

The Mayfair 1815CP 000 Soft Toilet Seat is the epitome of comfort and durability. The soft padded vinyl seat and wood core ensure a long-lasting, comfortable experience in the bathroom. The STA-TITE attachment system is effortless to install, providing a sturdy connection without any risk of wobbling. This classic chrome hinge not only adds style to your bath decor, but also strengthens the overall stability of the toilet seat.

One potential drawback is the quality inconsistency within the product line, as some users experienced premature tearing after just a few months. However, the majority of the customers reported lasting satisfaction with their purchases, praising the comfort and sturdiness of the toilet seat. Overall, the Mayfair Soft Toilet Seat is a worthy investment for those seeking a high-quality toilet seat replacement with a pinch of style.

Project Source Wood White Round Replacement Toilet Seat

project-source-wood-white-round-toilet-seat-1

The Project Source Wood White Round Toilet Seat is a durable option for replacing your existing toilet seat. Its white finish ensures a uniform look, while its simple design makes installation and cleaning a breeze. Compatible with any manufacturer’s round bowls, this seat provides comfort and ease of use in the bathroom.

Pros: The wooden construction provides durability and a sturdy feel, while the white finish offers an attractive and clean appearance. The design also makes the toilet seat easy to clean and install.

Cons: Some users have reported issues with the screws and hinges breaking or loosening over time, which can affect the seat’s durability and performance.

Overall, the Project Source Wood White Round Toilet Seat offers a reliable and affordable solution for replacing a worn-out or damaged toilet seat. Its wooden construction and simple design provide durability and ease of use, but users should be cautious about the risks of defective screws and hinges.

Buyer’s Guide

Whether you’re replacing an old, worn-out toilet seat or simply updating the look of your bathroom, there are several factors to consider when purchasing a new toilet seat replacement. This buyer’s guide will help you navigate the world of toilet seat replacements and make an informed decision.

Materials

Toilet seat replacements come in a variety of materials, each with its own advantages and drawbacks. Some common materials include plastic, wood, and bamboo. Plastic seats are typically the most affordable and lightweight, while wood and bamboo options tend to be more durable and eco-friendly. Consider the appearance, maintenance requirements, and your budget when choosing the material for your new toilet seat replacement.

Size

Toilet seat replacements come in multiple sizes to accommodate different bowl shapes and personal preferences. The most common size measurement is the distance between the front of the toilet seat and the center of the bolt holes. If you’re not sure which size to choose, measure your existing toilet seat and compare it to the available options. Keep in mind that some manufacturers offer elongated and round shapes, which may be better suited for specific toilet bowl designs.

Features

There are several features to look for when shopping for a toilet seat replacement. Some common features include slow-close hinges, which prevent slamming when closing the seat; quick-release mechanisms for easy removal; and bidet attachments for added convenience. Consider which features are most important to you and ensure the replacement seat you choose has them.

Installation

Installing a toilet seat replacement is typically a straightforward process, but there are a few things to keep in mind. Ensure that the replacement seat is compatible with your existing toilet bolts and that it comes with the necessary hardware for installation. Some seats may require special tools or adapters, so be sure to read the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. If you’re unsure about the installation process or need assistance, consider hiring a professional plumber for added peace of mind.

FAQ

Why should I replace my toilet seat?

You might have several reasons to swap out your toilet seat. Some common issues include aging, cracked, or damaged seats, an uncomfortable fit due to design or poor sizing, and a desire for a more visually appealing or cozy option. Replacing a worn-out seat can prevent potential infections, while opting for a more comfortable seat can enhance your overall bathroom experience.

Additionally, you might want to replace your toilet seat with one that is eco-friendly or water-saving, which can contribute to better bathroom habits and help conserve resources in the long run. Ultimately, the decision to replace your toilet seat is personal and can be influenced by various factors, such as your budget, preferences, and lifestyle.

How do I measure my toilet seat?

Measuring your toilet seat ensures that you select the perfect replacement. Begin by measuring the distance between the outer edges of the toilet bowl (rim to rim) while seated on the seat. Next, calculate the distance between the front of the toilet seat and the wall, taking the length of the toilet paper roll into account. Some seats come in standard sizes, such as round or elongated shapes, so consider these dimensions when purchasing a new one.

Lastly, don’t forget to check if the toilet seat is a one-piece or two-piece design. This information is crucial when choosing a replacement, as some two-piece seats need to be separated before installation. With these measurements handy, you can easily find a toilet seat that fits your toilet perfectly.

What materials are toilet seats made of?

Toilet seats are available in numerous materials, each with unique advantages and disadvantages. Some common materials include plastic, wood, bamboo, marble, and even recycled materials. Plastic is lightweight, resilient, and easy to clean, making it a popular choice. Wooden and bamboo seats offer a natural appearance, but they may require more frequent upkeep.

Marble seats are visually appealing but generally more expensive and delicate, with some even featuring an attached bidet. Recycled material seats are eco-friendly, durable, and sustainable, without requiring excessive maintenance. Consider your priorities, as well as the specific features of each material, when choosing the ideal toilet seat for your needs.

What is the difference between a round and elongated toilet seat?

The primary difference between round and elongated toilet seats lies in their shape. Round seats are designed to fit standard round toilets, while elongated seats are intended for elongated toilets with a slightly wider bowl. Elongated seats are typically more comfortable, but they may not fit in standard-sized bathrooms due to space constraints.

Round seats are often more affordable and suitable for smaller bathrooms, as they take up less space. However, if your current toilet seat is elongated, replacing it with a round seat might cause discomfort. Toilet manufacturers offer both round and elongated seats in various materials, so it’s essential to choose the appropriate shape for your toilet and your preferences.

Do toilet seats have gender differences?

The belief that toilet seats have gender differences is a common misconception. In reality, most seats have similar designs, materials, and features regardless of their intended gender. Gender-specific toilet seats may refer to color, texture, or branding more than any differences in the actual seat structure or functionality.

That said, the concept of “unisex” designs has emerged, offering neutral colors and aesthetics that appeal to a diverse range of individuals, regardless of their gender preferences. When shopping for toilet seats, focus on comfort, durability, and design, as these are the key factors that should guide your decision-making process.

How do I install a new toilet seat?

Installing a new toilet seat is a straightforward process that usually takes just a few steps. First, unscrew the old seat from the toilet bowl (if necessary) using a plumber’s wrench or your hands. Next, flip over the new seat and position it onto the toilet bowl, aligning the seat’s holes with the bolts on the underside of the bowl.

Secure the old bolts through the holes on the new seat using a plumber’s wrench or your hands, and then tighten the nuts on the bolts to secure the seat in place. It’s crucial to ensure the seat is level and centered between the wall and the toilet tank. Once installed, test the toilet seat by sitting on it, and make any necessary adjustments for optimal comfort and fit.

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualified purchases at no cost to you.

--

--